# global variables managing the state of the extension manager. treat as private. declare -A extension_function_info # maps a function name to a string with KEY=VALUEs information about the defining extension declare -i initialize_extension_manager_counter=0 # how many times has the extension manager initialized? declare -A defined_hook_point_functions # keeps a map of hook point functions that were defined and their extension info declare -A hook_point_function_trace_sources # keeps a map of hook point functions that were actually called and their source declare -A hook_point_function_trace_lines # keeps a map of hook point functions that were actually called and their source declare fragment_manager_cleanup_file # this is a file used to cleanup the manager's produced functions, for build_all_ng # configuration. export DEBUG_EXTENSION_CALLS=no # set to yes to log every hook function called to the main build log export LOG_ENABLE_EXTENSION=yes # colorful logs with stacktrace when enable_extension is called. # This is a helper function for calling hooks. # It follows the pattern long used in the codebase for hook-like behaviour: # [[ $(type -t name_of_hook_function) == function ]] && name_of_hook_function # but with the following added behaviors: # 1) it allows for many arguments, and will treat each as a hook point. # this allows for easily kept backwards compatibility when renaming hooks, for example. # 2) it will read the stdin and assume it's (Markdown) documentation for the hook point. # combined with heredoc in the call site, it allows for "inline" documentation about the hook # notice: this is not involved in how the hook functions came to be. read below for that. call_extension_method() { # First, consume the stdin and write metadata about the call. write_hook_point_metadata "$@" || true # @TODO: hack to handle stdin again, possibly with '< /dev/tty' # Then a sanity check, hook points should only be invoked after the manager has initialized. if [[ ${initialize_extension_manager_counter} -lt 1 ]]; then display_alert "Extension problem" "Call to call_extension_method() (in ${BASH_SOURCE[1]- $(get_extension_hook_stracktrace "${BASH_SOURCE[*]}" "${BASH_LINENO[*]}")}) before extension manager is initialized." "err" fi # With DEBUG_EXTENSION_CALLS, log the hook call. Users might be wondering what/when is a good hook point to use, and this is visual aid. [[ "${DEBUG_EXTENSION_CALLS}" == "yes" ]] && display_alert "--> Extension Method '${1}' being called from" "$(get_extension_hook_stracktrace "${BASH_SOURCE[*]}" "${BASH_LINENO[*]}")" "" # Then call the hooks, if they are defined. for hook_name in "$@"; do echo "-- Extension Method being called: ${hook_name}" >>"${EXTENSION_MANAGER_LOG_FILE}" # shellcheck disable=SC2086 [[ $(type -t ${hook_name}) == function ]] && { ${hook_name}; } done } # what this does is a lot of bash mumbo-jumbo to find all board-,family-,config- or user-defined hook points. # the meat of this is 'compgen -A function', which is bash builtin that lists all defined functions. # it will then compose a full hook point (function) that calls all the implementing hooks. # this centralized function will then be called by the regular Armbian build system, which is oblivious to how # it came to be. (although it is encouraged to call hook points via call_extension_method() above) # to avoid hard coding the list of hook-points (eg: user_config, image_tweaks_pre_customize, etc) we use # a marker in the function names, namely "__" (two underscores) to determine the hook point. initialize_extension_manager() { # before starting, auto-add extensions specified (eg, on the command-line) via the ENABLE_EXTENSIONS env var. Do it only once. [[ ${initialize_extension_manager_counter} -lt 1 ]] && [[ "${ENABLE_EXTENSIONS}" != "" ]] && { local auto_extension for auto_extension in $(echo "${ENABLE_EXTENSIONS}" | tr "," " "); do ENABLE_EXTENSION_TRACE_HINT="ENABLE_EXTENSIONS -> " enable_extension "${auto_extension}" done } # This marks the manager as initialized, no more extensions are allowed to load after this. export initialize_extension_manager_counter=$((initialize_extension_manager_counter + 1)) # Have a unique temporary dir, even if being built concurrently by build_all_ng. export EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR="${SRC}/.tmp/.extensions/${LOG_SUBPATH}" mkdir -p "${EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR}" # Log destination. export EXTENSION_MANAGER_LOG_FILE="${EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR}/extensions.log" echo -n "" >"${EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR}/hook_point_calls.txt" # globally initialize the extensions log. echo "-- lib/extensions.sh included. logs will be below, followed by the debug generated by the initialize_extension_manager() function." >"${EXTENSION_MANAGER_LOG_FILE}" # log whats happening. echo "-- initialize_extension_manager() called." >>"${EXTENSION_MANAGER_LOG_FILE}" # this is the all-important separator. local hook_extension_delimiter="__" # list all defined functions. filter only the ones that have the delimiter. get only the part before the delimiter. # sort them, and make them unique. the sorting is required for uniq to work, and does not affect the ordering of execution. # get them on a single line, space separated. local all_hook_points all_hook_points="$(compgen -A function | grep "${hook_extension_delimiter}" | awk -F "${hook_extension_delimiter}" '{print $1}' | sort | uniq | xargs echo -n)" declare -i hook_points_counter=0 hook_functions_counter=0 hook_point_functions_counter=0 # initialize the cleanups file. fragment_manager_cleanup_file="${SRC}"/.tmp/extension_function_cleanup.sh echo "# cleanups: " >"${fragment_manager_cleanup_file}" local FUNCTION_SORT_OPTIONS="--general-numeric-sort --ignore-case" # --random-sort could be used to introduce chaos local hook_point="" # now loop over the hook_points. for hook_point in ${all_hook_points}; do echo "-- hook_point ${hook_point}" >>"${EXTENSION_MANAGER_LOG_FILE}" # check if the hook point is already defined as a function. # that can happen for example with user_config(), that can be implemented itself directly by a userpatches config. # for now, just warn, but we could devise a way to actually integrate it in the call list. # or: advise the user to rename their user_config() function to something like user_config__make_it_awesome() local existing_hook_point_function existing_hook_point_function="$(compgen -A function | grep "^${hook_point}\$")" if [[ "${existing_hook_point_function}" == "${hook_point}" ]]; then echo "--- hook_point_functions (final sorted realnames): ${hook_point_functions}" >>"${EXTENSION_MANAGER_LOG_FILE}" display_alert "Extension conflict" "function ${hook_point} already defined! ignoring functions: $(compgen -A function | grep "^${hook_point}${hook_extension_delimiter}")" "wrn" continue fi # for each hook_point, obtain the list of implementing functions. # the sort order here is (very) relevant, since it determines final execution order. # so the name of the functions actually determine the ordering. local hook_point_functions hook_point_functions_pre_sort hook_point_functions_sorted_by_sort_id # Sorting. Multiple extensions (or even the same extension twice) can implement the same hook point # as long as they have different function names (the part after the double underscore __). # the order those will be called depends on the name; eg: # 'hook_point__033_be_awesome()' would be caller sooner than 'hook_point__799_be_even_more_awesome()' # independent from where they were defined or in which order the extensions containing them were added. # since requiring specific ordering could hamper portability, we reward extension authors who # don't mind ordering for writing just: 'hook_point__be_just_awesome()' which is automatically rewritten # as 'hook_point__500_be_just_awesome()'. # extension authors who care about ordering can use the 3-digit number, and use the context variables # HOOK_ORDER and HOOK_POINT_TOTAL_FUNCS to confirm in which order they're being run. # gather the real names of the functions (after the delimiter). hook_point_functions_pre_sort="$(compgen -A function | grep "^${hook_point}${hook_extension_delimiter}" | awk -F "${hook_extension_delimiter}" '{print $2}' | xargs echo -n)" echo "--- hook_point_functions_pre_sort: ${hook_point_functions_pre_sort}" >>"${EXTENSION_MANAGER_LOG_FILE}" # add "500_" to the names of function that do NOT start with a number. # keep a reference from the new names to the old names (we'll sort on the new, but invoke the old) declare -A hook_point_functions_sortname_to_realname declare -A hook_point_functions_realname_to_sortname for hook_point_function_realname in ${hook_point_functions_pre_sort}; do local sort_id="${hook_point_function_realname}" [[ ! $sort_id =~ ^[0-9] ]] && sort_id="500_${sort_id}" hook_point_functions_sortname_to_realname[${sort_id}]="${hook_point_function_realname}" hook_point_functions_realname_to_sortname[${hook_point_function_realname}]="${sort_id}" done # actually sort the sort_id's... # shellcheck disable=SC2086 hook_point_functions_sorted_by_sort_id="$(echo "${hook_point_functions_realname_to_sortname[*]}" | tr " " "\n" | LC_ALL=C sort ${FUNCTION_SORT_OPTIONS} | xargs echo -n)" echo "--- hook_point_functions_sorted_by_sort_id: ${hook_point_functions_sorted_by_sort_id}" >>"${EXTENSION_MANAGER_LOG_FILE}" # then map back to the real names, keeping the order.. hook_point_functions="" for hook_point_function_sortname in ${hook_point_functions_sorted_by_sort_id}; do hook_point_functions="${hook_point_functions} ${hook_point_functions_sortname_to_realname[${hook_point_function_sortname}]}" done # shellcheck disable=SC2086 hook_point_functions="$(echo -n ${hook_point_functions})" echo "--- hook_point_functions (final sorted realnames): ${hook_point_functions}" >>"${EXTENSION_MANAGER_LOG_FILE}" hook_point_functions_counter=0 hook_points_counter=$((hook_points_counter + 1)) # determine the variables we'll pass to the hook function during execution. # this helps the extension author create extensions that are portable between userpatches and official Armbian. # shellcheck disable=SC2089 local common_function_vars="HOOK_POINT=\"${hook_point}\"" # loop over the functions for this hook_point (keep a total for the hook point and a grand running total) for hook_point_function in ${hook_point_functions}; do hook_point_functions_counter=$((hook_point_functions_counter + 1)) hook_functions_counter=$((hook_functions_counter + 1)) done common_function_vars="${common_function_vars} HOOK_POINT_TOTAL_FUNCS=\"${hook_point_functions_counter}\"" echo "-- hook_point: ${hook_point} will run ${hook_point_functions_counter} functions: ${hook_point_functions}" >>"${EXTENSION_MANAGER_LOG_FILE}" local temp_source_file_for_hook_point="${EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR}/extension_function_definition.sh" hook_point_functions_loop_counter=0 # prepare the cleanup for the function, so we can remove our mess at the end of the build. cat <<-FUNCTION_CLEANUP_FOR_HOOK_POINT >>"${fragment_manager_cleanup_file}" unset ${hook_point} FUNCTION_CLEANUP_FOR_HOOK_POINT # now compose a function definition. notice the heredoc. it will be written to tmp file, logged, then sourced. # theres a lot of opportunities here, but for now I keep it simple: # - execute functions in the order defined by ${hook_point_functions} above # - define call-specific environment variables, to help extension authors to write portable extensions (eg: EXTENSION_DIR) cat <<-FUNCTION_DEFINITION_HEADER >"${temp_source_file_for_hook_point}" ${hook_point}() { echo "*** Extension-managed hook starting '${hook_point}': will run ${hook_point_functions_counter} functions: '${hook_point_functions}'" >>"\${EXTENSION_MANAGER_LOG_FILE}" FUNCTION_DEFINITION_HEADER for hook_point_function in ${hook_point_functions}; do hook_point_functions_loop_counter=$((hook_point_functions_loop_counter + 1)) # store the full name in a hash, so we can track which were actually called later. defined_hook_point_functions["${hook_point}${hook_extension_delimiter}${hook_point_function}"]="DEFINED=yes ${extension_function_info["${hook_point}${hook_extension_delimiter}${hook_point_function}"]}" # prepare the call context local hook_point_function_variables="${common_function_vars}" # start with common vars... (eg: HOOK_POINT_TOTAL_FUNCS) # add the contextual extension info for the function (eg, EXTENSION_DIR) hook_point_function_variables="${hook_point_function_variables} ${extension_function_info["${hook_point}${hook_extension_delimiter}${hook_point_function}"]}" # add the current execution counter, so the extension author can know in which order it is being actually called hook_point_function_variables="${hook_point_function_variables} HOOK_ORDER=\"${hook_point_functions_loop_counter}\"" # add it to our (not the call site!) environment. if we export those in the call site, the stack is corrupted. eval "${hook_point_function_variables}" # output the call, passing arguments, and also logging the output to the extensions log. # attention: don't pipe here (eg, capture output), otherwise hook function cant modify the environment (which is mostly the point) # @TODO: better error handling. we have a good opportunity to 'set -e' here, and 'set +e' after, so that extension authors are encouraged to write error-free handling code cat <<-FUNCTION_DEFINITION_CALLSITE >>"${temp_source_file_for_hook_point}" hook_point_function_trace_sources["${hook_point}${hook_extension_delimiter}${hook_point_function}"]="\${BASH_SOURCE[*]}" hook_point_function_trace_lines["${hook_point}${hook_extension_delimiter}${hook_point_function}"]="\${BASH_LINENO[*]}" [[ "\${DEBUG_EXTENSION_CALLS}" == "yes" ]] && display_alert "---> Extension Method ${hook_point}" "${hook_point_functions_loop_counter}/${hook_point_functions_counter} (ext:${EXTENSION:-built-in}) ${hook_point_function}" "" echo "*** *** Extension-managed hook starting ${hook_point_functions_loop_counter}/${hook_point_functions_counter} '${hook_point}${hook_extension_delimiter}${hook_point_function}':" >>"\${EXTENSION_MANAGER_LOG_FILE}" ${hook_point_function_variables} ${hook_point}${hook_extension_delimiter}${hook_point_function} "\$@" echo "*** *** Extension-managed hook finished ${hook_point_functions_loop_counter}/${hook_point_functions_counter} '${hook_point}${hook_extension_delimiter}${hook_point_function}':" >>"\${EXTENSION_MANAGER_LOG_FILE}" FUNCTION_DEFINITION_CALLSITE # output the cleanup for the implementation as well. cat <<-FUNCTION_CLEANUP_FOR_HOOK_POINT_IMPLEMENTATION >>"${fragment_manager_cleanup_file}" unset ${hook_point}${hook_extension_delimiter}${hook_point_function} FUNCTION_CLEANUP_FOR_HOOK_POINT_IMPLEMENTATION # unset extension vars for the next loop. unset EXTENSION EXTENSION_DIR EXTENSION_FILE EXTENSION_ADDED_BY done cat <<-FUNCTION_DEFINITION_FOOTER >>"${temp_source_file_for_hook_point}" echo "*** Extension-managed hook ending '${hook_point}': completed." >>"\${EXTENSION_MANAGER_LOG_FILE}" } # end ${hook_point}() function FUNCTION_DEFINITION_FOOTER # unsets, lest the next loop inherits them unset hook_point_functions hook_point_functions_sortname_to_realname hook_point_functions_realname_to_sortname # log what was produced in our own debug logfile cat "${temp_source_file_for_hook_point}" >>"${EXTENSION_MANAGER_LOG_FILE}" cat "${fragment_manager_cleanup_file}" >>"${EXTENSION_MANAGER_LOG_FILE}" # source the generated function. # shellcheck disable=SC1090 source "${temp_source_file_for_hook_point}" rm -f "${temp_source_file_for_hook_point}" done # Dont show any output until we have more than 1 hook function (we implement one already, below) [[ ${hook_functions_counter} -gt 0 ]] && display_alert "Extension manager" "processed ${hook_points_counter} Extension Methods calls and ${hook_functions_counter} Extension Method implementations" "info" | tee -a "${EXTENSION_MANAGER_LOG_FILE}" } cleanup_extension_manager() { if [[ -f "${fragment_manager_cleanup_file}" ]]; then display_alert "Cleaning up" "extension manager" "info" # this will unset all the functions. # shellcheck disable=SC1090 # dynamic source, thanks, shellcheck source "${fragment_manager_cleanup_file}" fi # reset/unset the variables used initialize_extension_manager_counter=0 unset extension_function_info defined_hook_point_functions hook_point_function_trace_sources hook_point_function_trace_lines fragment_manager_cleanup_file } # why not eat our own dog food? # process everything that happened during extension related activities # and write it to the log. also, move the log from the .tmp dir to its # final location. this will make run_after_build() "hot" (eg, emit warnings) run_after_build__999_finish_extension_manager() { # export these maps, so the hook can access them and produce useful stuff. export defined_hook_point_functions hook_point_function_trace_sources # eat our own dog food, pt2. call_extension_method "extension_metadata_ready" <<'EXTENSION_METADATA_READY' *meta-Meta time!* Implement this hook to work with/on the meta-data made available by the extension manager. Interesting stuff to process: - `"${EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR}/hook_point_calls.txt"` contains a list of all hook points called, in order. - For each hook_point in the list, more files will have metadata about that hook point. - `${EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR}/hook_point.orig.md` contains the hook documentation at the call site (inline docs), hopefully in Markdown format. - `${EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR}/hook_point.compat` contains the compatibility names for the hooks. - `${EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR}/hook_point.exports` contains _exported_ environment variables. - `${EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR}/hook_point.vars` contains _all_ environment variables. - `${defined_hook_point_functions}` is a map of _all_ the defined hook point functions and their extension information. - `${hook_point_function_trace_sources}` is a map of all the hook point functions _that were really called during the build_ and their BASH_SOURCE information. - `${hook_point_function_trace_lines}` is the same, but BASH_LINENO info. After this hook is done, the `${EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR}` will be removed. EXTENSION_METADATA_READY # Move temporary log file over to final destination, and start writing to it instead (although 999 is pretty late in the game) mv "${EXTENSION_MANAGER_LOG_FILE}" "${DEST}/${LOG_SUBPATH:-debug}/extensions.log" export EXTENSION_MANAGER_LOG_FILE="${DEST}/${LOG_SUBPATH:-debug}/extensions.log" # Cleanup. Leave no trace... [[ -d "${EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR}" ]] && rm -rf "${EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR}" } # This is called by call_extension_method(). To say the truth, this should be in an extension. But then it gets too meta for anyone's head. write_hook_point_metadata() { local main_hook_point_name="$1" [[ ! -d "${EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR}" ]] && mkdir -p "${EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR}" cat - >"${EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR}/${main_hook_point_name}.orig.md" # Write the hook point documentation received via stdin to a tmp file for later processing. shift echo -n "$@" >"${EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR}/${main_hook_point_name}.compat" # log the 2nd+ arguments too (those are the alternative/compatibility names), separate file. compgen -A export >"${EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR}/${main_hook_point_name}.exports" # capture the exported env vars. compgen -A variable >"${EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR}/${main_hook_point_name}.vars" # capture all env vars. # add to the list of hook points called, in order. echo "${main_hook_point_name}" >>"${EXTENSION_MANAGER_TMP_DIR}/hook_point_calls.txt" } # Helper function, to get clean "stack traces" that do not include the hook/extension infrastructure code. get_extension_hook_stracktrace() { local sources_str="$1" # Give this ${BASH_SOURCE[*]} - expanded local lines_str="$2" # And this # Give this ${BASH_LINENO[*]} - expanded local sources lines index final_stack="" IFS=' ' read -r -a sources <<<"${sources_str}" IFS=' ' read -r -a lines <<<"${lines_str}" for index in "${!sources[@]}"; do local source="${sources[index]}" line="${lines[((index - 1))]}" # skip extension infrastructure sources, these only pollute the trace and add no insight to users [[ ${source} == */.tmp/extension_function_definition.sh ]] && continue [[ ${source} == *lib/extensions.sh ]] && continue [[ ${source} == */compile.sh ]] && continue # relativize the source, otherwise too long to display source="${source#"${SRC}/"}" # remove 'lib/'. hope this is not too confusing. source="${source#"lib/"}" # add to the list arrow="$([[ "$final_stack" != "" ]] && echo "-> ")" final_stack="${source}:${line} ${arrow} ${final_stack} " done # output the result, no newline # shellcheck disable=SC2086 # I wanna suppress double spacing, thanks echo -n $final_stack } show_caller_full() { local frame=0 while caller $frame; do ((frame++)) done } # can be called by board, family, config or user to make sure an extension is included. # single argument is the extension name. # will look for it in /userpatches/extensions first. # if not found there will look in /extensions # if not found will exit 17 declare -i enable_extension_recurse_counter=0 declare -a enable_extension_recurse_stack enable_extension() { local extension_name="$1" local extension_dir extension_file extension_file_in_dir extension_floating_file local stacktrace # capture the stack leading to this, possibly with a hint in front. stacktrace="${ENABLE_EXTENSION_TRACE_HINT}$(get_extension_hook_stracktrace "${BASH_SOURCE[*]}" "${BASH_LINENO[*]}")" # if LOG_ENABLE_EXTENSION, output useful stack, so user can figure out which extensions are being added where [[ "${LOG_ENABLE_EXTENSION}" == "yes" ]] && display_alert "Extension being added" "${extension_name} :: added by ${stacktrace}" "" # first a check, has the extension manager already initialized? then it is too late to enable_extension(). bail. if [[ ${initialize_extension_manager_counter} -gt 0 ]]; then display_alert "Extension problem" "already initialized -- too late to add '${extension_name}' (trace: ${stacktrace})" "err" exit 2 fi # check the counter. if recurring, add to the stack and return success if [[ $enable_extension_recurse_counter -gt 1 ]]; then enable_extension_recurse_stack+=("${extension_name}") return 0 fi # increment the counter enable_extension_recurse_counter=$((enable_extension_recurse_counter + 1)) # there are many opportunities here. too many, actually. let userpatches override just some functions, etc. for extension_base_path in "${SRC}/userpatches/extensions" "${EXTER}/extensions"; do extension_dir="${extension_base_path}/${extension_name}" extension_file_in_dir="${extension_dir}/${extension_name}.sh" extension_floating_file="${extension_base_path}/${extension_name}.sh" if [[ -d "${extension_dir}" ]] && [[ -f "${extension_file_in_dir}" ]]; then extension_file="${extension_file_in_dir}" break elif [[ -f "${extension_floating_file}" ]]; then extension_dir="${extension_base_path}" # this is misleading. only directory-based extensions should have this. extension_file="${extension_floating_file}" break fi done # After that, we should either have extension_file and extension_dir, or throw. if [[ ! -f "${extension_file}" ]]; then echo "ERR: Extension problem -- cant find extension '${extension_name}' anywhere - called by ${BASH_SOURCE[1]}" exit 17 # exit, forcibly. no way we can recover from this, and next extensions will get bogus errors as well. fi local before_function_list after_function_list new_function_list # store a list of existing functions at this point, before sourcing the extension. before_function_list="$(compgen -A function)" # error handling during a 'source' call is quite insane in bash after 4.3. # to be able to catch errors in sourced scripts the only way is to trap declare -i extension_source_generated_error=0 trap 'extension_source_generated_error=1;' ERR # source the file. extensions are not supposed to do anything except export variables and define functions, so nothing should happen here. # there is no way to enforce it though, short of static analysis. # we could punish the extension authors who violate it by removing some essential variables temporarily from the environment during this source, and restore them later. # shellcheck disable=SC1090 source "${extension_file}" # remove the trap we set. trap - ERR # decrement the recurse counter, so calls to this method are allowed again. enable_extension_recurse_counter=$((enable_extension_recurse_counter - 1)) # test if it fell into the trap, and abort immediately with an error. if [[ $extension_source_generated_error != 0 ]]; then display_alert "Extension failed to load" "${extension_file}" "err" exit 4 fi # get a new list of functions after sourcing the extension after_function_list="$(compgen -A function)" # compare before and after, thus getting the functions defined by the extension. # comm is oldskool. we like it. go "man comm" to understand -13 below new_function_list="$(comm -13 <(echo "$before_function_list" | sort) <(echo "$after_function_list" | sort))" # iterate over defined functions, store them in global associative array extension_function_info for newly_defined_function in ${new_function_list}; do extension_function_info["${newly_defined_function}"]="EXTENSION=\"${extension_name}\" EXTENSION_DIR=\"${extension_dir}\" EXTENSION_FILE=\"${extension_file}\" EXTENSION_ADDED_BY=\"${stacktrace}\"" done # snapshot, then clear, the stack local -a stack_snapshot=("${enable_extension_recurse_stack[@]}") enable_extension_recurse_stack=() # process the stacked snapshot, finally enabling the extensions for stacked_extension in "${stack_snapshot[@]}"; do ENABLE_EXTENSION_TRACE_HINT="RECURSE ${stacktrace} ->" enable_extension "${stacked_extension}" done }